Adapt the situation using new details · Evaluating a colleague's proposal

A 72–112 word writing task with a model and self-review.

Adapt the situation using new details for "Evaluating a colleague's proposal". Apply these two focuses: Acknowledging a strength before identifying a limitation; Evaluating an idea rather than its author. Write 72–112 words using real or invented details. Try writing before opening the model.
Show a model for comparison

Practical examples

The proposal addresses a real difficulty, and its emphasis on clearer ownership is useful. My concern is that the suggested timetable leaves little space for consultation with the teams affected. This is a limitation of the implementation plan rather than an objection to the overall aim. A short consultation stage could reveal dependencies that are not yet reflected in the schedule. I would therefore support developing the proposal further, provided that this stage is included. That would preserve the main benefit while making the plan more realistic.

يعالج المقترح صعوبة حقيقية، ويفيد تركيزه على وضوح المسؤولية. موضع قلقي أن الجدول المقترح لا يتيح وقتًا كافيًا للتشاور مع الفرق المتأثرة. هذا قيد في خطة التنفيذ، لا اعتراض على الهدف العام. قد تكشف مرحلة تشاور قصيرة عن متطلبات مترابطة لا يعكسها الجدول بعد. لذلك، أؤيد تطوير المقترح أكثر، بشرط إدراج هذه المرحلة. سيحافظ ذلك على الفائدة الرئيسية، مع جعل الخطة أكثر واقعية.

Review your writing

This is a self-review; your writing is not automatically graded.